Print this page

75% of Recent and Prospective Homebuyers Are Concerned About Homeowners Insurance Becoming Unaffordable, New Realtor.com® Survey

Written by Posted On Friday, 12 September 2025 06:26
75% of Recent and Prospective Homebuyers Are Concerned About Homeowners Insurance Becoming Unaffordable, New Realtor.com® Survey

Half face or expect to face trouble obtaining and renewing insurance, with some saying that they could forgo homeowners insurance altogether

As more than one in four homes in the U.S.—representing $12.7 trillion in real estate value—risk exposure to severe or extreme climate risks, nearly half of recent and prospective homebuyers have faced trouble or expect to face trouble obtaining or renewing homeowners insurance, according to a recent Realtor.com® survey. Eighty-eight percent of those surveyed believe that they will pay for more homeowners insurance in the future and 42% have already confirmed they have experienced a rise in home insurance costs. Notably, 75% believe that homeowners insurance could ultimately become unaffordable.

According to the survey, 58% of recent and prospective homebuyers said that they would or are likely to forgo homeowners insurance if the costs became too high–a decision some have already made. This increases to 76% among Gen Z buyers, even though many of these young buyers are using a mortgage and therefore likely required to have homeowners insurance. 65% of those surveyed are worried about obtaining and maintaining their homeowners insurance. 

“Homeowners insurance offers financial protection for consumers that may help cover damage to homes and personal property from an extreme weather event or fire, while also providing personal property and liability coverage,” said Realtor.com® Chief Economist, Danielle Hale. “But these benefits come with an upfront cost that has risen as weather events have become more frequent and impactful and rebuilding costs climb. Homeowners are looking for strategies to lower costs including adjusting their home searches and potentially short-charging or forgoing coverage altogether.” 

According to the survey’s findings, insurance challenges have forced one third (33.7%) of home searchers to completely change the geographic area where they are looking for a home and another 30% have cast a wider net and expanded their initial target geography. Nearly one quarter of home searchers have completely changed strategies based on insurance challenges. 

Additionally, just 30% have looked into the natural disaster risk data for their home or prospective homes, though 44% plan to do so in the future.

Gen Z home searchers are more likely to have taken some type of action in their search to potentially mitigate against homeowners insurance challenges compared to other generations, especially Baby Boomers who said that only 6% had completely changed their homebuying strategy and only 15% had expanded their initial search.  

Definitely applies

Probably applies

Does not apply

Homeowners insurance has risen in cost over the past 2 years

42.1%

31.3%

26.6%

Expect to pay more for homeowners insurance in the future 

45.2% 

43.3% 

11.5%

Faced recent challenges obtaining homeowners insurance

20.7% 

27.9% 

51.4%

Faced recent challenges renewing homeowners insurance

20.1% 

27.5% 

52.4%

If the cost of homeowner insurance continues to rise, it could become unaffordable

31.2% 

44.1% 

24.7%

Would consider foregoing homeowners insurance if the costs became too high

23.6% 

35.1% 

41.3%

Worried about obtaining or maintaining homeowners insurance

27.2% 

38.0% 

34.8%

Gen Z

Gen Y

Gen X

Baby Boom

Completely changed strategy based on insurance challenges 

30.5%

25.9%

19.9%

5.9%

Expanded initial target geography 

32.5%

32.2%

32.8%

15.8%

Eliminated some desired locations 

35.8%

36.0%

33.2%

25.7%

No impact yet, but expect it will in the future 

18.5%

19.3%

23.7%

32.2%

No change

15.9%

16.0%

14.9%

32.9%

According to a recent Realtor.com report, 26 percent – representing $12.7 trillion in value – of  U.S. homes face severe climate risks including flooding, wildfire, or hurricane wind damage. These severe climate risks result in higher insurance premiums for homeowners, amplifying the financial strain on homeowners in high-risk areas. For single-family homeowners under a HO-3 policy, the most common type of homeowners insurance policy in the U.S., in Miami the typical homeowner now pays annual premiums equal to 3.7 percent of the home’s market value—the highest ratio among the nation’s 100 largest metros. 

Methodology

This sample of 1,000 US adults (aged 18+) was surveyed from August 7th to August 8th, 2025. All respondents indicated that they are currently interested in buying or selling their primary residence or have done so within the past two years.

Rate this item
(0 votes)
Move Inc

Realtor.com® is an open real estate marketplace built for everyone. Realtor.com® pioneered the world of digital real estate more than 25 years ago. Today, through its website and mobile apps, Realtor.com® is a trusted guide for consumers, empowering more people to find their way home by breaking down barriers, helping them make the right connections, and creating confidence through expert insights and guidance. For professionals, Realtor.com® is a trusted partner for business growth, offering consumer connections and branding solutions that help them succeed in today’s on-demand world. Realtor.com® is operated by News Corp [Nasdaq: NWS, NWSA] [ASX: NWS, NWSLV] subsidiary Move, Inc. For more information, visit Realtor.com®.

https://www.realtor.com/

Latest from Move Inc

Joomla! Debug Console

Session

Profile Information

Memory Usage

Database Queries